Roy Keane tyrmää Manchester Unitedin kriisin Amorim paineessa ja fanit vaativat muutosta

It’s starting to feel like déjà vu at Old Trafford. A new season, fresh hope, and then—just a few games in—a crushing reality check. Four matches gone, only four points on the board, and Manchester United already sitting 14th in the Premier League. If the low start wasn’t enough, Sunday’s derby against City made things brutally clear: United don’t just trail their noisy neighbors, they got obliterated by them. A 3–0 beating in their own backyard left fans streaming out of Old Trafford long before the final whistle.

And then came Roy Keane.

Anyone who’s watched the Irishman on TV knows he doesn’t bother with niceties. As a player, he terrified teammates. As a pundit, he terrifies managers. After watching City stroll through United like it was a training exercise, Keane didn’t hesitate: “Manchester United,” he said flatly, “are a mid-table team.”

Keane Calls It As He Sees It

For Keane, the problem isn’t just results—it’s the feeling. The fight, the hunger, the belief that United were once famous for… it’s just not there. Sure, he’ll admit they can string together the occasional good spell—like the first half against Arsenal—but the reality, he says, is that they can’t sustain it. Not against the big guns.

The stats back him up. Against the Premier League’s top sides over the past few years, United’s record has been grim: far more defeats than wins, with every clash against City, Liverpool, or Arsenal looking like a mountain too high.

To Keane, this is deeper than tactics or formations. It cuts to what Manchester United used to mean. Old Trafford, he reminded viewers, wasn’t a place where you hoped to give the big boys a game. It was where you came to win. That edge, that aura—it’s gone.

The Manager Under Fire: Rúben Amorim

In the dugout, Rúben Amorim is already feeling the heat. Hired with big promises and backed with even bigger transfer spending—more than £200 million since last season—he was supposed to kickstart a new era. Instead, his United look alarmingly familiar to the teams that stumbled before him.

The checklist of problems is a painful one for fans:

• A defense that cracks whenever a top-class attack turns up.
• A midfield with no bite or balance.
• An attack built on moments instead of structure, hoping for individual brilliance.

Keane made comparisons too. Look at Liverpool: last summer they brought in Arne Slot, another fresh face with new ideas. Same timing, same pressures—but Slot delivered a title. Meanwhile, United, despite their heavy spending, are stuck in familiar fits and starts. And fans are asking outright: why has Slot transformed Liverpool while Amorim hasn’t managed the same at Old Trafford?

Excuses or a Real Crisis?

For now, the United hierarchy insists Amorim has their backing. But there’s no hiding from what’s plain to see: this team lacks a clear identity, consistency, and—perhaps worst of all—belief.

The list of issues is clear:

• Against top teams: too weak, both mentally and tactically.
• Transfers: big chequebooks, small rewards.
• Roles: too many players look lost in the system.
• Belief: no confidence when facing rivals like City or Liverpool.

The most telling sign came off the pitch: thousands of fans walking out long before full-time, an image that spoke louder than any analysis. Supporters are loyal, but they’re weary of another season stuck in the middle of the table.

What Happens Next?

There isn’t much breathing room. Next up are Tottenham and Newcastle, both in form and eager to add to United’s misery. How many more setbacks can Amorim afford before patience snaps completely—both in the stands and the boardroom?

Roy Keane has already delivered his verdict. The excuses are gone. United must find answers quickly or find a new man to lead them. The bigger question for fans is chilling: was Sunday’s derby defeat the lowest point—or just the beginning of another long, frustrating season?

Possible New Headlines

• “Roy Keane: United Are Just a Mid-Table Team”
• “Amorim Under Fire as Keane Questions United’s Identity”
• “No More Excuses: Keane Demands Change at Manchester United”

Key Highlights

1. United’s season has started poorly, with only 4 points from 4 matches.
2. A 3–0 loss to City exposed the gap between the two Manchester clubs.
3. Roy Keane labeled United a mid-table team in their current state.
4. Manager Rúben Amorim has spent heavily but inspired little progress.
5. Upcoming fixtures against Tottenham and Newcastle could make or break his tenure.

👉 What about you—do you think Keane’s criticism is fair, or should Amorim be given more time to stamp his mark on Manchester United?